The Independent Community Group (ICG)

Home
About the ICG
The New Administration - A Statement
Local News
Heathrow Expansion
Keeping a Keen Eye
Councillors' Surgeries
Join/Donate
Links
Contact Us

Heathrow Expansion

The latest news and views

planeoverroof.jpg

Keens show true colours over Heathrow expansion

10a_27_10aALAN-KE_415x275.jpg

MP’s Ann and Alan Keen (left) have dealt another body blow to the residents of the London Borough of Hounslow by siding with the government over a Conservative led motion calling for a re-think over plans to build a third runway at Heathrow Airport.

Despite repeated claims that both MP’s are against airport expansion, they both voted against the motion, which was not binding, claiming that the Tories were trying to hijack the moral high ground over the environment.

 

Speaking during the debate, Alan keen said:

 

I say straight away that I am going to vote against the Opposition motion on the grounds that it is, without any doubt, party politicking.”

“I was sitting in the second row here in the Chamber when the Secretary of State announced the barring of mixed mode. I looked at the faces of Conservative Members whom I have often regarded as colleagues during my years of opposing the third runway, and there was not a smile on any of their faces. That is how I know that the motion is party politicking; there is no doubt about that. What is more, they know it.”

It seems that Mr. Keen was still celebrating his ‘victory’ from the previous week, but there can be little doubt about one thing though, not many people in Hounslow and Sipson would have been smiling along with Mr. Keen when Geoff Hoon was announcing his plans to demolish a thriving community, and pour further misery on thousands of residents living near Heathrow, for the very same reasons given by Conservative MP Justine Greening, who said:

“The reason why there were not many smiles on this side is that we get the same old story. No promise on Heathrow expansion has ever been followed through. Every statement about Heathrow has always gone something like, “We’re going to get on with this expansion, and that will mean that we won’t need that other expansion.””

In the end the government won the vote by just 19. Had all ‘New Labour’ MP’s that claim to be against Heathrow expansion had the guts to stick to their convictions, Gordon Brown would have had to deal with a humiliating defeat. As it is Ann and Alan Keen continue to demonstrate their undivided loyalty to the government.

It comes as no surprise that there are calls for Ann Keen to follow the example set by fellow Labour MP’s Andrew Slaughter and Virendra Sharma, who quit their junior government posts over the issue, to resign her own post as Junior Health Minister, so that she can represent her constituents without any allegiance to the Prime Minister. Given her performance over the expenses scandal, this would appear to be highly unlikely.

 
 
Keens claim "partial victory" over Heathrow expansion

Following Geoff Hoon’s  decision to go ahead with the planned expansion of Heathrow Airport, announced in the House of Commons on 15th January 2009, MP’s Ann and Alan Keen (Brentford and Isleworth & Feltham and Heston respectively) issued a joint statement in which they claim to have won a “partial” victory in the fight against Heathrow expansion, in an extraordinary attempt to save face.

 

In fact the only thing that residents have to celebrate is the fact that the government plan to keep runway alternation. The ending of the Cranford agreement and the decision to go ahead with the third runway will mean a huge increase in noise pollution for residents living on the edge of the northern runway in Cranford, and the destruction of an entire community as the village of Sipson will be demolished to make way for the new runway.

 

Outraged by the MP’s claims, Isleworth councillor, Paul Fisher, was compelled to write the following letter to the Hounslow Chronicle:

 

Dear Sir,

 

In an extraordinary joint press statement released by Ann and Alan Keen, MP’s for Brentford & Isleworth and Feltham & Heston respectively, the couple claim to have had a “partial victory” in the fight to halt plans to build a third runway and further expansion at Heathrow Airport.

 

The statement comes days after the Secretary of State for Transport, Geoff Hoon, announced the government’s plans to allow a third runway to be built at Heathrow, in the House of Commons on 15th January 2009.

 

The statement, published by the Chronicle newspaper, claims that the decision to keep runway alternation means that there will be “no increase in noise pollution” for residents. What the government aren’t so keen to tell us is that the levels of noise that BAA would have to adhere to are based on figures that included the noise from Concord when it was still flying, which produced noise levels equivalent to 150 planes per day. Furthermore, Alan Keen, speaking for both MP’s, claimed that “this is the first major refusal that the government has ever made to the industry and it’s a major one. It’s a fantastic victory.” He continues by saying “We have put our arguments, and those of our constituents, against the expansion of Heathrow and its operations directly to the Prime Minister and the Secretaries of State. This result on mixed mode is proof that they have listened.”

 

However residents in Cranford had very little to celebrate as there was no such victory for them when Mr. Hoon also announced that he would be ending the Cranford agreement, which is a “gentleman’s” agreement dating back to 1952 and meant that wherever possible aircraft would not take off in an easterly direction from the northern runway as it is so close to residential properties.

 

The Keens do not appear to have commented on this issue in their statement, however, in the House of Commons, at around the same time as Labour MP for Hayes and Harlington, John McDonnell, was being escorted off of the premises for removing the ceremonial mace in an act of passionate protest against Mr. Hoon’s decision, Alan Keen had this to say: “Even though the Cranford agreement is going, which I am sad about, that will at least benefit the constituents in Maidenhead, Windsor and places like that. We have to give and take on such issues.”

 

We must also give a thought to the people of Sipson, the village that will be raised to the ground by the bulldozers in order to facilitate the third runway. While Mr and Mrs Keen were celebrating their victory, the residents of Sipson, who will be doing most of the “giving” if the plans to build the third runway go ahead, were coming to terms with the fact that they could be about to loose their homes.

 

The ICG remain as committed as ever in its opposition to further expansion of Heathrow Airport and we will continue to fight alongside those that share this view. The Mayor of London, Boris Johnson, is looking into the possibility of a legal challenge. The various organisations against Heathrow expansion are no doubt planning their next move and the residents of Sipson remain defiant with some threatening to chain themselves to the bulldozers if they arrive.

 

It is also fair to say that John McDonnell can expect to receive some sort of heroes welcome when he returns to his constituency. The same cannot be said for Mr and Mrs Keen. If past experience is anything to go by, we can expect them to lay low for a while in order for the dust to settle. When they do eventually manage to drag themselves away from their luxury apartment in Westminster and return to their constituencies, they can expect a rather more hostile reception, which, if Alan Keen’s recent prediction comes true, will result in them both loosing their seats at the next general election. For many that day cannot come too soon.

 

Yours,

 

Councillor Paul Fisher, Independent Community Group (ICG), Isleworth Ward.

 
 
 
Community reminds Ann Keen of "the inconvenient truth" about Heathrow
 

MEMBERS of the local community demonstrated outside Holiday Inn, Brentford recently where Brentford & Isleworth MP Ann Keen hosted a screening of Al Gore's inspirational documentary An Inconvenient Truth, which highlights the dangers of climate change.

 

Mrs. Keen arrived at the hotel early to avoid the demonstration, although fans arrived whilst the demonstration was in full swing and were engaged by the protesters who gave them leaflets (see pictures below).

 

The demonstrators waved placards and handed out leaflets to draw attention to the fact that the New Labour government, members of which were flaunted by Mrs. Keen at the event, had presided over an increase of nearly 40,000 flights per year at Heathrow since the general election of 1997.

 

The demonstration was organised by the Independent Community Group (ICG), and was supported by members of the Liberal Democrats including the party's local group leader Councillor Andrew Dakers.  Despite having received an invitation to the screening, Councillor Dakers was later refused entry to the event by the Keens.

 

Also present at the demonstration was a delegation of residents from Cranford, led by former Labour councillor Parmod Kad MBE.  Members of Friends of the Earth managed to attend the event.

 

Leaflets handed out by the demonstrators pointed out that in October 2005 Ann Keen had voted against a bill which would have limited the number of night flights using Heathrow - then a week later attended a rally opposing airport expansion!

 

Speaking after the event, Community Group councillor Phil Andrews commented: "Ann Keen is to be commended for staging this event, but the big names she flaunts are the very same people who are backing the expansion of Heathrow at the expense of our local community.

 

"Mrs. Keen demonstrated once again in 2005 that her own career and personal advancement mean more to her than her own constituents, who continue to suffer the effects of night flights.

 

"Under the circumstances this event would seem to have more to do with keeping her own name in the headlines than with an honest attempt to highlight the very real problem of climate change."

 

Mr. Kad added:  "Every time I see an aeroplane flying over Cranford in the middle of the night disturbing our sleep and all day discharging noise and air pollution over Cranford, and every time I see a young child or elderly person coughing with asthma due to air pollution in Cranford, I pray to God in desperation for a better elected political representatives for Cranford and Hounslow who cared to understand our difficulties. Lack of representation of Cranford councillors at this event exhibits their lack of commitment to the environment".

 

holidayinn1.jpg

Above: Demonstrators outside the Holiday Inn protest against airport expansion.
 
Below: An ICG protester greets Labour councillors Nisar Malik and Pritam Grewal as they arrive at the event.

holidayinn2.jpg

www.communitygroup.org.uk